The Cincinnati Reds have offered shortstop Elly De La Cruz a 13-year contract extension with a potential total value of $700 million, according to reports circulating this week. The offer would make De La Cruz the highest-paid player in franchise history and place him among baseball's top-three contracts by total dollars, trailing only Shohei Ohtani's $700 million Dodgers deal and Juan Soto's pending free agency.
De La Cruz, 23, is entering his third major league season and won't reach arbitration until 2026 or free agency until 2029. He slashed .259/.346/.477 with 25 home runs and an MLB-leading 67 stolen bases in 2024, his first full season. The Reds finished 77-85, fourth in the NL Central, but drew 2.09 million fans to Great American Ball Park, up 14% year-over-year. De La Cruz led the team in jersey sales and appeared in 11 national broadcasts, the most for a Red since Joey Votto's 2017 season.
The structure matters more than the headline. Extension frameworks in this range typically include deferrals, vesting options tied to plate appearances or All-Star selections, and buyout clauses for the club's final seasons. Ohtani's Dodgers contract defers $680 million until after 2033, lowering the present-day value to roughly $460 million. If Cincinnati's offer includes similar mechanics, the annual average value could land between $40 million and $50 million depending on discount rate and performance triggers. The Reds' 2024 payroll ranked 26th at $101 million. Signing De La Cruz to a $50 million AAV would consume half the current budget before arbitration raises for pitchers Hunter Greene and Nick Lodolo, both entering their first arb year in 2026.
Small-market clubs rarely commit nine-figure extensions to pre-arb players. The last comparable: Milwaukee's 8-year, $100 million deal with Christian Yelich in 2020, signed after his MVP season. That contract is now an albatross; Yelich posted a .681 OPS in 2024. Cincinnati's ownership group, led by Bob Castellini, has historically operated as a net seller at the deadline. The franchise hasn't signed a player to a contract exceeding $75 million since Votto's 10-year, $225 million extension in 2012. That deal paid Votto $25 million annually through his age-39 season. He retired in 2023 after hitting .202.
The Reds' calculus hinges on regional media revenue and naming rights. The club is negotiating a new local broadcast deal after Diamond Sports' bankruptcy unwound their previous Bally Sports Ohio contract. Comparable Midwest markets—Kansas City, Milwaukee—are securing annual rights fees between $45 million and $60 million in the post-RSN landscape. De La Cruz's marketability could justify a premium. He's Dominican, bilingual, and averaging 1.2 million Instagram followers, more than any Red since the platform launched. Great American Ball Park's naming rights deal with Great American Insurance expires in 2027. The company paid $75 million over 30 years in the original 2000 agreement; renewal could approach $10 million annually if the Reds field a contender.
Cincinnati's front office, led by president of baseball operations Nick Krall, has been methodical. They extended India to a 5-year, $26 million deal in 2023 and locked up Greene on a 6-year, $53 million pact last spring. Both contracts bought out arbitration years at below-market rates. Extending De La Cruz would signal a shift: instead of trading stars before free agency, the Reds would build around one and fill gaps with mid-tier pitching. The farm system ranks 18th per MLB Pipeline, with no position players in the top-100 prospect list. There is no replacement coming.
The market for elite shortstops resets annually. Trea Turner signed 11 years, $300 million with Philadelphia in 2022. Corey Seager took 10 years, $325 million from Texas the same winter. Both players were 28 at signing. De La Cruz is five years younger, with comparable power-speed metrics and worse plate discipline—his 28.7% strikeout rate ranked 11th-highest among qualified shortstops. Clubs typically discount pre-prime extensions by 20-30% to account for development risk. A true-value contract for De La Cruz in free agency might approach $500 million; the Reds' $700 million offer likely includes back-loaded years, options, or milestone bonuses that inflate the ceiling.
Watch whether De La Cruz's representation—Excel Sports Management, which also reps Soto—engages seriously. Excel's strategy has been to push clients to free agency and maximize bidding wars. Soto turned down the Nationals' 15-year, $440 million offer in 2022; he'll sign for $600 million-plus this winter. If De La Cruz waits until 2029, a robust economy and expanded playoff revenue could push his market past $800 million. The risk: injury, regression, or a second straight Reds rebuild that erodes his leverage.
Cincinnati's offer is public now, which means De La Cruz's camp leaked it or the front office did. Either way, the negotiation has moved from private to political. If he signs, the Reds sell 10,000 season-ticket packages before Opening Day. If he declines, every trade deadline becomes a referendum. Krall's extension runs through 2027. He'll need an answer before then.