Ohio State dropped its first home game to Nebraska since 1958, a 21-17 defeat that arrives seven weeks after the Big Ten signed media rights worth $7.5 billion over seven years, predicated partly on multiple teams reaching the expanded 12-team College Football Playoff.
The Buckeyes entered Saturday ranked second nationally and favored by 25.5 points. They generated 64 yards rushing, converted 3-of-14 third downs, and allowed a Nebraska program that had lost 26 consecutive games to ranked opponents to control pace. Indiana, the conference's surprise 10-0 story, fell to Ohio State 38-15 hours earlier, exposing a schedule strength problem that now threatens its at-large candidacy. The Big Ten sent two teams to last year's four-team playoff; the conference's internal models assumed four bids minimum under expansion.
The operational problem is bracket math. Tennessee dismantled Georgia 31-17 in Athens, handing the Bulldogs their second loss and vaulting the Volunteers into the 8-10 seed range depending on Sunday's selection committee release. That compresses available slots. The SEC will claim three to four bids; the ACC winner takes one; Notre Dame, at 9-1, holds another. Big Ten commissioner Tony Petitti told conference ADs in October that playoff revenue distribution—$6 million per team, $4 million per game win—would help offset the lack of a conference championship game payout for teams finishing third or fourth in standings. Those projections assumed Oregon, Ohio State, Penn State, and Indiana all clearing 10 wins. Indiana now sits 10-1 with a resume including zero wins over current top-25 teams. Ohio State, at 9-2, has losses to unranked Oregon and Nebraska, the latter by double digits at home.
The ripple reaches sponsorship. The Big Ten secured $500 million from Fox, NBC, and CBS on the promise of appointment viewing through December. Indiana's collapse strips the conference of its Cinderella narrative; Ohio State's loss removes the drama of an undefeated Columbus-Eugene rematch. The conference's New York headquarters had already war-gamed scheduling around a presumed Buckeyes-Ducks Big Ten title game on December 7 in Indianapolis, with Lucas Oil Stadium's local ad inventory priced assuming both teams arrived undefeated. That window closed Saturday.
What the CFP committee does with Indiana now informs how every future bubble team schedules. The Hoosiers played one road game against a team that finished ranked, lost by 23, and compiled ten wins against programs with a combined 8-39 record versus Power Four opponents. If Indiana holds a top-12 seed Sunday, every athletic director will replicate the formula: backload cupcakes, win your division, trust the committee to reward record over résumé. If Indiana falls out, the sport reverts to pre-expansion logic, and the Big Ten's four-bid model becomes two, maybe three, depending on Penn State's outcome at Minnesota.
Tennessee's win matters because it was clean. The Volunteers forced two turnovers, held Georgia to 68 rushing yards, and covered the spread as 9.5-point underdogs. That's a data point the committee weighs heavily: road dominance against a top-5 team. The SEC now has Tennessee, Texas, Alabama, and Georgia all inside the top 12 with two weeks remaining. Ole Miss, at 8-2, waits behind them. The Big Ten has Oregon, Ohio State, Penn State, and Indiana, but the gap between third and fifth in committee perception just widened.
Petitti's next call is Wisconsin athletic director Chris McIntosh, the conference's playoff liaison. McIntosh briefs the committee Tuesday on tiebreaker scenarios if Penn State loses and Indiana drops another spot. The conference's expansion revenue model—publicly positioned as a $60-80 million annual boost per school—assumes consistent playoff depth. Two bids instead of four cuts that figure nearly in half. Meanwhile, SEC commissioner Greg Sankey is already floating five-bid scenarios in background calls with committee members, citing Tennessee's performance as proof of league depth.
Ohio State's offensive line coach Justin Frye is not expected back for 2025; his unit allowed five sacks Saturday and has regressed in pass protection for three straight weeks. Indiana head coach Curt Cignetti, whose $8 million annual salary was justified by this exact season, now faces December bowl placement that could land the Hoosiers in the Citrus or ReliaQuest rather than a New Year's Six game, cutting program exposure and recruiting momentum.
The selection committee releases updated rankings Sunday at 7pm ET. Tennessee will jump at least three spots; Indiana will fall at least two. The Big Ten's four-bid assumption gets tested in real time, and the conference's media partners will adjust December ad rates by Monday morning based on which teams remain viable.