Diego Pavia, the former Vanderbilt quarterback who finished second in Heisman voting seven months ago, was selected first overall by the Columbus Aviators in Thursday's UFL Draft. He will report to Columbus in February for a ten-week spring season that runs through mid-April, positioning him for NFL minicamp invitations in May.
Pavia threw for 3,879 yards and 34 touchdowns in his final college season, leading Vanderbilt to its first bowl win in fifteen years. His draft stock collapsed in January when an NCAA eligibility panel ruled that his two seasons at New Mexico Military Institute—a junior college—counted against his college clock, leaving him with no remaining eligibility and eliminating any possibility of a graduate transfer that might have improved his NFL tape. He went undrafted in April's NFL Draft. No team signed him as a priority free agent.
The UFL route solves a specific problem: live reps against professional defenses with NFL scouts in attendance, all while maintaining eligibility for July's supplemental NFL draft if Columbus releases him after the season. The Aviators run a spread-option system under head coach Jimmie Dougherty, formerly offensive coordinator at Washington State, which mirrors the tempo Pavia ran at Vanderbilt. Columbus finished 4-6 last season and missed the playoffs. The team's general manager, Mike Rowe, told reporters Thursday that Pavia will start Week 1 against the Michigan Panthers on February 15.
Pavia's agent, Trace Armstrong of Wasserman, negotiated a one-year deal worth approximately $250,000 base salary with performance escalators tied to playoff appearances and individual accolades. That figure sits at the top of UFL quarterback compensation, slightly above what Birmingham pays John Rhys Plumlee ($235,000). Armstrong declined to confirm whether the contract includes an NFL opt-out clause, though league sources say such provisions are standard for first-round UFL picks with remaining NFL runway.
The timing matters for two reasons. First, Pavia turns 24 in March, placing him at the upper edge of the developmental quarterback window that NFL teams typically target. Second, the UFL season ends April 20, giving him roughly three weeks to audition for teams before rookie minicamps begin in mid-May. Last year, five UFL quarterbacks received minicamp invitations, though none made a 53-man roster. The calculus shifts if Pavia posts a passer rating above 95 and shows functional pocket awareness, two areas where his Vanderbilt tape graded poorly among draft analysts.
Columbus ownership, led by Larry Gottesdiener's Northland Investment Corporation, has already committed $12 million in stadium renovations ahead of the 2026 season, suggesting the franchise intends to remain in Ohio rather than relocate. Pavia's jersey went on sale within ninety minutes of the draft selection. The Aviators' season-ticket base stands at approximately 8,200, well below the league average of 11,500. Gottesdiener told the Columbus Dispatch in September that the team needs to exceed 10,000 season tickets to break even on operations.
Pavia's collegiate eligibility fight attracted three federal lawsuits and a Tennessee state court ruling that briefly reinstated him before the NCAA's final decision in January. His attorney, Ryan Downton, argued that JUCO seasons should not count toward the NCAA's five-year clock because those institutions are not NCAA members. The ruling set no binding precedent but clarified that any post-high-school competition in a recognized football league counts toward eligibility, a standard that affects roughly 1,200 current JUCO players nationwide.
Watch whether Columbus adds a veteran backup quarterback before training camp opens in late January. The Aviators currently roster Will Grier and Anthony Brown, both of whom have UFL starting experience. If Pavia struggles in February scrimmages, Dougherty has cover to pivot without embarrassing the franchise's marquee draft pick. NFL scouts will attend Columbus home games on March 1, March 22, and April 6—the three dates that fall between the NFL Combine (February 25-28) and pro days (late March). Armstrong has already fielded interest from four teams, according to a person familiar with the conversations, though none have committed to predraft visits.
The UFL Draft's second pick, offensive lineman Jonah Savaiinaea from Arizona, went to San Antonio. He signed for $180,000.